Ron DeSantis's Reorganization of New College Florida: A Critical Examination

In recent months, Governor Ron DeSantis of Florida has taken a keen interest in the state's public universities, particularly New College of Florida (NCF), a small liberal arts institution located in Sarasota. DeSantis has proposed a series of changes to the college, including overhauling its board of trustees, revising its curriculum, and altering its admissions policies. These proposals have sparked a heated debate among educators, students, and the general public, raising questions about academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the role of government in higher education. In this article, we will delve into the details of DeSantis's plans for NCF, explore the potential implications of these changes, and examine the broader context of his actions within the landscape of Florida's higher education system.

DeSantis's interest in NCF is not entirely surprising. As a conservative Republican, he has consistently expressed skepticism towards institutions of higher education, often accusing them of promoting liberal bias and stifling free speech. He has also been a vocal critic of critical race theory (CRT), an academic framework that examines the role of race and racism in American society. DeSantis's proposals for NCF seem to reflect these ideological positions, as they aim to reshape the college in a way that aligns more closely with his political views.

The implications of DeSantis's plans for NCF are wide-ranging and multifaceted. Critics argue that these changes will undermine the college's academic integrity and reputation, stifle intellectual inquiry, and discourage diversity of thought. They also fear that the politicization of NCF will deter prospective students and faculty from seeking affiliation with the institution. On the other hand, supporters of DeSantis's proposals contend that they are necessary to restore balance and prevent NCF from becoming a bastion of liberal indoctrination. They argue that the changes will improve the quality of education at the college and make it more responsive to the needs of Florida's students and taxpayers.

ron desantis new college florida

Governor's controversial proposals for liberal arts college.

• Overhaul of board of trustees
• Revision of curriculum
• Changes to admissions policies
• Allegations of political interference
• Concerns over academic freedom
• Debate about institutional autonomy
• Impact on NCF's reputation and enrollment
• Implications for Florida's higher education system

DeSantis's plans for NCF have ignited a heated debate about the role of government in higher education and the future of academic freedom in Florida.

Overhaul of board of trustees

At the heart of DeSantis's proposed changes to New College Florida is a plan to overhaul the college's board of trustees. Currently, the board consists of 13 members, appointed by the governor and confirmed by the state senate. DeSantis's proposal would increase the number of board members to 15 and give the governor the power to appoint all of them, without the need for senate confirmation. This would effectively give DeSantis complete control over the board and allow him to appoint individuals who share his political views and support his agenda for the college.

Critics of DeSantis's proposal argue that it would undermine the independence and autonomy of New College. They point out that the board of trustees is responsible for overseeing the college's academic and financial affairs, and that giving the governor unilateral control over the board would politicize the institution and stifle academic freedom. They also worry that DeSantis would use his power to appoint board members who are unqualified or who would prioritize ideological conformity over academic excellence.

Supporters of DeSantis's proposal, on the other hand, argue that it is necessary to restore balance and accountability to New College. They claim that the current board is dominated by liberal ideologues who have allowed the college to drift away from its original mission. They also argue that the governor, as the elected leader of the state, should have the authority to appoint the board members who will oversee public institutions like New College.

The debate over DeSantis's proposed overhaul of the board of trustees is likely to continue for some time. The outcome of this debate will have a significant impact on the future of New College Florida and could set a precedent for how other public universities in Florida are governed.

DeSantis's proposal to overhaul the board of trustees is just one part of his broader plan to reshape New College Florida. His other proposals include revising the curriculum, changing admissions policies, and increasing state oversight of the college. These changes, taken together, would fundamentally alter the character of New College and bring it more in line with DeSantis's conservative political agenda.

Revision of curriculum

In addition to overhauling the board of trustees, DeSantis has also proposed a revision of the curriculum at New College Florida. Specifically, he has called for the elimination of majors and programs that focus on critical race theory, gender studies, and other subjects that he deems to be "woke" or "indoctrinating." He has also proposed a new core curriculum that would require all students to take courses in American history, civics, and economics.

Critics of DeSantis's proposed curriculum changes argue that they would undermine the academic integrity and reputation of New College. They point out that the college is known for its strong liberal arts education and that its faculty are experts in their respective fields. They also argue that the elimination of certain majors and programs would limit the educational opportunities available to students and make it more difficult for them to pursue their academic interests.

Supporters of DeSantis's proposed curriculum changes, on the other hand, argue that they are necessary to restore balance and rigor to New College. They claim that the current curriculum is biased towards liberal ideology and that it does not adequately prepare students for the workforce. They also argue that the new core curriculum would provide students with a well-rounded education and help them to develop critical thinking skills.

The debate over DeSantis's proposed curriculum changes is likely to continue for some time. The outcome of this debate will have a significant impact on the educational experience of students at New College Florida and could set a precedent for how other public universities in Florida approach curriculum development.

DeSantis's proposal to revise the curriculum is just one part of his broader plan to reshape New College Florida. His other proposals include overhauling the board of trustees, changing admissions policies, and increasing state oversight of the college. These changes, taken together, would fundamentally alter the character of New College and bring it more in line with DeSantis's conservative political agenda.

Changes to admissions policies

• Eliminating affirmative action. DeSantis has proposed eliminating affirmative action in admissions at New College Florida. This would mean that the college would no longer be able to use race or ethnicity as a factor in admissions decisions.
• Raising the minimum GPA requirement. DeSantis has also proposed raising the minimum GPA requirement for admission to New College Florida. This would make it more difficult for students with lower GPAs to be admitted to the college.
• Requiring all applicants to take the SAT or ACT. DeSantis has also proposed requiring all applicants to New College Florida to take the SAT or ACT exam. This would eliminate the test-optional policy that the college currently has in place.

Allegations of political interference

One of the most controversial aspects of DeSantis's plans for New College Florida is the allegation that he is attempting to use his power as governor to interfere with the college's academic and administrative affairs. Critics of DeSantis point to a number of incidents as evidence of this interference, including:

• The appointment of a conservative majority to the board of trustees. As mentioned earlier, DeSantis has proposed overhauling the board of trustees at New College Florida and giving himself the power to appoint all of the members. Critics argue that this move is an attempt to stack the board with individuals who share DeSantis's political views and who will support his agenda for the college.
• The proposed curriculum changes. DeSantis has also proposed a number of changes to the curriculum at New College Florida, including the elimination of majors and programs that focus on critical race theory, gender studies, and other subjects that he deems to be "woke" or "indoctrinating." Critics argue that these changes are politically motivated and that they would undermine the academic integrity and reputation of the college.
• The investigation into the college's diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives. In January 2023, DeSantis announced that his administration would be investigating DEI initiatives at New College Florida and other public universities in the state. Critics argue that this investigation is a witch hunt designed to intimidate faculty and staff who are working to promote diversity and inclusion on campus.

DeSantis and his supporters deny that he is interfering with New College Florida. They argue that he is simply exercising his authority as governor to ensure that the college is fulfilling its mission and providing a high-quality education to its students. However, the allegations of political interference are likely to continue as long as DeSantis continues to push for changes at the college.

The allegations of political interference at New College Florida are part of a larger pattern of DeSantis's attempts to exert control over public education in the state. In recent years, DeSantis has signed into law a number of bills that restrict the teaching of certain subjects in public schools and universities. He has also appointed conservative majorities to the boards of trustees of several public universities, including the University of Florida and Florida State University.

Concerns over academic freedom

One of the biggest concerns about DeSantis's plans for New College Florida is that they would stifle academic freedom and prevent faculty from teaching and researching the subjects they are most passionate about.

• The proposed curriculum changes. As mentioned earlier, DeSantis has proposed a number of changes to the curriculum at New College Florida, including the elimination of majors and programs that focus on critical race theory, gender studies, and other subjects that he deems to be "woke" or "indoctrinating." Critics argue that these changes would限制 the range of topics that faculty can teach and research, and that they would create a hostile environment for scholars who work in these fields.
• The investigation into DEI initiatives. DeSantis's investigation into DEI initiatives at New College Florida and other public universities in the state has also raised concerns about academic freedom. Critics argue that this investigation is an attempt to intimidate faculty and staff who are working to promote diversity and inclusion on campus. They worry that this investigation could lead to faculty members being punished or even fired for expressing views that are critical of the governor or his administration.
• The appointment of a conservative majority to the board of trustees. DeSantis's appointment of a conservative majority to the board of trustees at New College Florida has also raised concerns about academic freedom. Critics worry that the new board members will use their power to micromanage the college's academic affairs and to punish faculty members who do not share their political views.

The concerns over academic freedom at New College Florida are not just theoretical. In recent months, there have been a number of reports of faculty members at the college being harassed or intimidated for their political views or for teaching about subjects that are controversial. For example, one professor was reportedly told by a student that they would be "reported" to the governor for teaching about critical race theory. Another professor was reportedly told by a colleague that they should "keep their politics to themselves" in the classroom.

These incidents have created a climate of fear and intimidation at New College Florida, and they have made many faculty members reluctant to speak out against DeSantis's plans for the college. This is a serious threat to academic freedom, and it could have a lasting impact on the quality of education at the college.

Debate about institutional autonomy

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida have also reignited a debate about institutional autonomy. Institutional autonomy refers to the ability of colleges and universities to govern themselves without undue interference from outside forces, such as the government or political leaders. Supporters of institutional autonomy argue that it is essential for academic freedom and the pursuit of knowledge. They argue that colleges and universities should be free to set their own curricula, hire their own faculty, and determine their own policies without being subject to political pressure.

Critics of DeSantis's plans argue that they represent a serious threat to institutional autonomy. They point out that DeSantis is attempting to use his power as governor to micromanage the affairs of New College Florida. They argue that this is an abuse of power and that it sets a dangerous precedent for the future of higher education in Florida.

The debate about institutional autonomy is not just a theoretical one. In recent years, there have been a number of cases of state governments interfering with the affairs of public colleges and universities. For example, in 2021, the governor of Texas signed a law that禁止 public universities from offering courses on critical race theory. In 2022, the governor of Florida signed a law that requires public universities to survey their students and faculty about their political beliefs.

These laws are just two examples of the growing trend of government interference in higher education. DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are part of this trend, and they represent a serious threat to institutional autonomy. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it could have a chilling effect on academic freedom and the pursuit of knowledge at New College Florida and other public universities in the state.

The debate about institutional autonomy is likely to continue for some time. The outcome of this debate will have a significant impact on the future of higher education in Florida and across the United States.

Impact on NCF's reputation and enrollment

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are likely to have a significant impact on the college's reputation and enrollment. Many prospective students and faculty are likely to be discouraged from attending a college that is seen as being politically polarized and hostile to academic freedom. This could lead to a decline in the quality of education at the college and make it more difficult for NCF to attract top talent.

There is already some evidence that DeSantis's plans are having a negative impact on NCF's reputation. In recent months, the college has seen a decline in applications from prospective students. The college has also lost several faculty members, who have resigned in protest of DeSantis's plans. This brain drain is likely to continue if DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans for the college.

The decline in NCF's reputation and enrollment is a serious concern for the future of the college. NCF is a small, liberal arts college that has a long history of academic excellence. If DeSantis's plans are successful, NCF could be transformed into a second-rate institution that is no longer able to attract top students and faculty. This would be a tragedy for the college and for the state of Florida.

In addition to the impact on NCF's reputation and enrollment, DeSantis's plans could also have a negative impact on the local economy. NCF is a major employer in the Sarasota area, and the college contributes millions of dollars to the local economy each year. If NCF's enrollment declines, this could lead to job losses and a decline in economic activity in the area.

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are a serious threat to the college's reputation, enrollment, and financial stability. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it could have a devastating impact on the college and the community that surrounds it.

Implications for Florida's higher education system

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are also likely to have a broader impact on the state's higher education system. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it could set a precedent for other public colleges and universities in Florida. This could lead to a decline in academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education at public universities throughout the state.

• Increased political interference. DeSantis's plans for New College Florida represent a significant increase in political interference in higher education. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it could embolden other politicians to interfere in the affairs of public colleges and universities. This could lead to a decline in academic freedom and institutional autonomy.
• Brain drain. DeSantis's plans for New College Florida have already led to a number of faculty members resigning in protest. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it is likely that more faculty members will leave the state. This brain drain could have a negative impact on the quality of education at public universities throughout Florida.
• Decline in enrollment. DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are likely to discourage prospective students from attending public colleges and universities in Florida. This could lead to a decline in enrollment at public universities throughout the state.
• Damage to Florida's reputation. DeSantis's attacks on New College Florida and other public universities in the state are damaging Florida's reputation as a place to get a high-quality education. This could make it more difficult for Florida's public universities to attract top students and faculty.

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are a serious threat to the state's higher education system. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it could lead to a decline in academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education at public universities throughout the state. This would be a tragedy for Florida and for the future of higher education in the United States.

In addition to the points listed above, DeSantis's plans for New College Florida could also have a negative impact on the state's economy. Public universities are a major economic driver in Florida, and they contribute billions of dollars to the state's economy each year. If DeSantis's plans lead to a decline in enrollment and a brain drain, this could have a negative impact on the state's economy.

FAQ

Introduction:

Here are some frequently asked questions about Ron DeSantis's plans for New College Florida:

Question 1: What are DeSantis's plans for New College Florida?

Answer: DeSantis has proposed a number of changes to New College Florida, including overhauling the board of trustees, revising the curriculum, changing admissions policies, and increasing state oversight of the college.

Question 2: Why is DeSantis proposing these changes?

Answer: DeSantis has stated that he believes that New College Florida has become too liberal and that it needs to be reformed in order to provide a more well-rounded education to its students.

Question 3: What are the concerns about DeSantis's plans?

Answer: Critics of DeSantis's plans argue that they would undermine academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education at New College Florida. They also worry that DeSantis is using his power as governor to interfere with the college's affairs for political reasons.

Question 4: What are the potential consequences of DeSantis's plans for New College Florida?

Answer: If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, it could lead to a decline in academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education at New College Florida. It could also discourage prospective students and faculty from attending the college, leading to a decline in enrollment. Additionally, DeSantis's plans could set a precedent for other politicians to interfere in the affairs of public colleges and universities, which could have a negative impact on higher education in Florida and across the United States.

Question 5: What can be done to stop DeSantis's plans?

Answer: There are a number of things that can be done to stop DeSantis's plans. One is to contact your state legislators and let them know that you oppose DeSantis's plans. You can also donate to organizations that are working to protect academic freedom and institutional autonomy in higher education. Additionally, you can spread the word about DeSantis's plans and encourage others to speak out against them.

Question 6: What is the future of New College Florida?

Answer: The future of New College Florida is uncertain. If DeSantis is successful in implementing his plans, the college could be transformed into a second-rate institution that is no longer able to attract top students and faculty. However, if DeSantis's plans are stopped, New College Florida can continue to be a thriving liberal arts college that provides a high-quality education to its students.

Closing:

These are just some of the questions and answers about DeSantis's plans for New College Florida. The situation is still developing, and it is unclear what the future holds for the college. However, one thing is for sure: DeSantis's plans are a serious threat to academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education at New College Florida and other public universities in Florida.

Transition:

In addition to the information provided in the FAQ, here are some tips for staying informed about DeSantis's plans for New College Florida and other issues related to higher education in Florida:

Tips

Introduction:

Here are some tips for staying informed about DeSantis's plans for New College Florida and other issues related to higher education in Florida:

Tip 1: Follow reliable news sources.

There are a number of reliable news sources that cover education in Florida. Some of these sources include the Tampa Bay Times, the Orlando Sentinel, the Miami Herald, and the Florida Phoenix. You can also follow education reporters on Twitter or subscribe to their newsletters.

Tip 2: Attend public meetings and events.

Public meetings and events are a great way to learn more about DeSantis's plans for New College Florida and other issues related to higher education in Florida. You can find information about upcoming meetings and events on the websites of the Florida Board of Governors and the Florida Department of Education.

Tip 3: Contact your state legislators.

Your state legislators represent you in the Florida legislature. They have the power to pass laws that can protect or undermine higher education in Florida. You can contact your state legislators by phone, email, or mail. Let them know your thoughts on DeSantis's plans for New College Florida and other issues related to higher education.

Tip 4: Get involved with organizations that are fighting for academic freedom and institutional autonomy.

There are a number of organizations that are working to protect academic freedom and institutional autonomy in higher education. Some of these organizations include the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), and the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE). You can get involved with these organizations by donating money, volunteering your time, or spreading the word about their work.

Closing:

By following these tips, you can stay informed about DeSantis's plans for New College Florida and other issues related to higher education in Florida. You can also take action to protect academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education in Florida.

Transition:

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are a serious threat to the college and to higher education in Florida. However, there are a number of things that can be done to stop DeSantis's plans. By staying informed, getting involved, and taking action, we can protect academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education in Florida.

Conclusion

Summary of Main Points:

Ron DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are a serious threat to the college and to higher education in Florida. DeSantis's plans would overhaul the board of trustees, revise the curriculum, change admissions policies, and increase state oversight of the college. These changes would undermine academic freedom, institutional autonomy, and the quality of education at New College Florida. They would also discourage prospective students and faculty from attending the college, leading to a decline in enrollment.

DeSantis's plans for New College Florida are part of a larger pattern of his attempts to exert control over public education in the state. In recent years, DeSantis has signed into law a number of bills that restrict the teaching of certain subjects in public schools and universities. He has also appointed conservative majorities to the boards of trustees of several public universities, including the University of Florida and Florida State University.

DeSantis's attacks on higher education are a threat to the future of Florida. A well-educated population is essential for a thriving economy and a healthy democracy. DeSantis's plans would make it more difficult for Florida students to get a high-quality education, and they would discourage top talent from coming to Florida to teach and do research.

Closing Message:

We must not let DeSantis destroy higher education in Florida. We must speak out against his plans and we must support the students, faculty, and administrators who are fighting to protect academic freedom and institutional autonomy. The future of Florida's higher education system is at stake.

We must not let this happen. We must stand up for academic freedom and institutional autonomy. We must fight for the future of higher education in Florida.